The 2010 regular draft order determines draft selections for all but the first 8 picks of round 1, which is determined by a draft lottery.
Draft order is defined in the league rules as 1) worst record through best record of non-money-winning teams; followed by 2) low money won to high money won. Tiebreaker for identical records is total points (record and points based on week 14 standings).
- New Chester (3-11)
- Miami (5-9; 544 pts.)
- Syracuse (5-9; 592 pts.)
- Mercer (5-8-1)
- Dallas (6-8; 603 pts.)
- Richburgh (6-8; 719 pts.)
- Happy Valley (6-8; 720 pts.)
- MassIll (8-6)
- Keystone (6th $ won)
- Boston (5th $ won)
- Frelinghuysen (4th $ won)
- Oregon (3rd $ won)
- Orange County (2nd $ won)
- Philadelphia (1st $ won)