ROUND 1
- Pittsburgh – Lawrence Phillips, RB, Rams
- Miami – Eddie George, RB, Oilers
- Dallas – Aaron Hayden, RB, Chargers
- Mercer – Vincent Brisby, WR, Patriots
- New York (from RD) – Edgar Bennett, RB, Packers
- State College – Tim Biakabatuka, RB, Panthers
- Keystone – Leeland McElroy, RB, Cardinals
- New York (from NP) – Adrian Murrell, RB, Jets
- Butler – Leroy Hoard, RB, Ravens
- Los Angeles – Mike Alstott – RB, Tampa Bay
- Carolina – Chris Sanders, WR, Oilers
- Pennsylvania – Karim Abdul-Jabbar, RB, Dolphins
- Pittsburgh (from RD, from WN) – Michael Haynes, WR, Saints
- Newport (from NY) – Keyshawn Johnson, WR, Jets
ROUND 2
- Pennsylvania (from PG) – Quinn Early, WR, Bills
- Mercer – Tony Martin, WR, Chargers
- Miami – Jake Reed, WR, Vikings
- Los Angeles (from DS) – Marvin Harrison, WR, Colts
- New York (from RD) – Charlie Garner, RB, Eagles
- State College – Tamarick Vanover, WR, Chiefs
- Newport – Jim Kelly, QB, Bills
- Keystone – Terry Glenn, WR, Patriots
- Butler – James Stewart, RB, Jaguars
- Los Angeles – Larry Centers, RB, Cards
- Carolina – Tommy Vardell, RB, 49ers
- Pennsylvania – Chris T. Jones, WR, Eagles
- Wisconsin – Antonio Freeman, WR, Packers
- New York – Mark Brunnell, QB, Jaguars
EXTRA PICKS FOR THOSE NOT PROTECTING FULL 5
- Dallas – Darrick Holmes, RB, Bills
- Richmond – Neil O’Donnell, QB, Jets
- Wisconsin – Shannon Sharpe, TE, Broncos
ROUND 3
- Keystone – Jim Harbaugh, QB, Colts
- Newport – Eddie Kennison, WR, Rams
- Butler (from PG) – Kevin Williams, WR, Cowboys
- Mercer – Aaron Craver, RB, Broncos
- Miami – Erik Kramer, QB, Bears
- Dallas – Derrick Mayes, WR, Packers
- Pittsburgh (from RD) – Johnnie Morton, WR, Lions
- State College – Pete Stoyanovich, K, Chiefs
- Butler – Torrance Small, WR, Saints
- Los Angeles – Dorsey Levens, RB, Packers
- Los Angeles (from CL) – LeShon Johnson, RB, Cards
- Pennsylvania – Rick Mirer, QB, Seahawks
- Wisconsin – Raymont Harris, RB, Bears
- Los Angeles (from NY) – Leonard Russell, RB, Chargers
ROUND 4
- Newport – Eric Moulds, WR, Bills
- Keystone – Rodney Thomas, RB, Oilers
- New York – Frank Sanders, WR, Cards
- Butler – Zack Crockett, RB, Colts
- State College – Stan Humphries, QB, Chargers
- Pittsburgh (from RD) – Kordell Stewart, WR, Steelers
- Pennsylvania – Sean Dawkins, WR, Colts
- Mercer – Sherman Williams, RB, Cowboys
- Los Angeles – Tony Banks, QB, Rams
- Carolina – Napolean Kaufman, RB, Raiders
- Miami – Doug Pelfrey, K, Bengals
- Pittsburgh – Chris Boniol, K, Cowboys
- Wisconsin – William Floyd, RB, 49ers
- Dallas – Gus Frerotte, QB, Redskins
EXPANSION TEAM EXTRAS
- Keystone – Jeff Wilkins, K, 49ers
- New York (from NP) – Steve Bono, QB, Chiefs
ROUND 5
- Newport – Irving Spikes, RB, Dolphins
- Keystone – Alvin Harper, WR, Bucs
- Richmond (from PG) – Marco Battaglia, TE, Bengals
- Mercer – Vinny Testeverde, QB, Ravens
- Miami – Brian Blades, WR, Seahawks
- Dallas – Henry Ellard, WR, Redskins
- Richmond – Brian Mitchell, RB, Redskins
- State College – Jerry Ellison, RB, Bucs
- Butler – Lake Dawson, WR, Chiefs
- Los Angeles – Steve Walsh, QB, Rams
- Carolina – Erric Pegram, RB, Steelers
- Pennsylvania – Terrell Fletcher, RB, Chargers
- Wisconsin – Travis Jervey, RB, Packers
- New York – Jamal Anderson, RB, Falcons
ROUND 6
- Keystone – Bobby Engram, WR, Bears
- Newport – Randal Hill, WR, Dolphins
- Pittsburgh – Lamont Warren, RB, Colts
- Mercer – Troy Drayton, TE, Rams
- Miami – Lamar Thomas, WR, Dolphins
- Dallas – Chris Jacke, K, Packers
- Pittsburgh (from RD) – Chris Chandler, QB, Oilers
- State College – Terrell Owens, WR, 49ers
- Butler – Irv Smith, TE, New Orleans
- Los Angeles – Bam Morris, RB **disallowed**
- Carolina – Jerris McPhail, RB, Dolphins
- Pittsburgh (from PA) – Steve Christie, K, Bills
- Wisconsin – Shawn Jefferson, WR, Patriots
- New York – Lamar Smith, RB, Seahawks
ROUND 7
- Newport – Mo Williams, RB, Vikings
- Keystone – Winslow Oliver, RB, Panthers
- Pittsburgh – Michael Timpson, WR, Bears
- Mercer – John Carney, K, Chargers
- Miami – Alex Van Dyke, WR, Jets
- Dallas – Mark Carrier, WR, Panthers
- Richmond – Andre Hastings, WR, Steelers
- State College – Willie Davis, WR, Oilers
- Butler – Brad Baxter, RB, Jets
- Los Angeles – Fred Barnett, WR, Dolphins (IR)
- Carolina – Stephen Davis, RB, Redskins
- Pennsylvania – Kyle Brady, TE, Jets
- Wisconsin – Mushim Muhammed, WR, Panthers
- New York – John Kasay, K, Panthers
ROUND 8
- Keystone – Ty Detmer, QB, Eagles
- Newport – Doug Brien, K, Saints
- Pittsburgh – Kenyon Rasheed, WR, Jets (IR)
- Mercer – Raghib Ismael, WR, Raiders
- Miami – Reggie Brooks, RB, Bucs
- Mercer (from NY, from DS) – Dino Philyaw, RB, Panthers
- Richmond – Nick Lowery, K, Jets
- State College – Joe Nedney, K, Dolphins
- Butler – Boomer Esiason, QB, Cards
- Los Angeles – Deion Sanders, WR, Cowboys
- Carolina – Keenan McCardell, WR, Jaguars
- Pennsylvania – Ed McCaffrey, WR, Broncos
- Wisconsin – Rodney Peete, QB, Eagles
- New York – Chris Darkins, RB, Packers
ROUND 9
- Newport – Keith Byars, RB, Dolphins
- Keystone (EXTRA) – pass
- Pittsburgh (EXTRA) – pass
- Mercer – (EXTRA) – pass
- Miami – Michael Husted, K, Bucs
- Dallas – Haywood Jeffries, WR, Saints
- Richmond – Courtney Hawkins, WR, Bucs
- State College – Derek Brown, RB, Saints
- Butler (EXTRA) – pass
- Los Angeles- (EXTRA) – pass
- Carolina – Eric Zeier, QB, Ravens
- Pennsylvania – Adam Vintieri, K, Patriots
- Wisconsin – Leslie Sheppard, WR, Redskins
- New York (EXTRA) – pass
EXTRA PICKS TO FILL ROSTER
- Dallas – Bryan Still, WR, Chargers
- Richmond – Mike Sherrard, WR, Broncos
- Carolina – Scott Sisson, K, Vikings
- Wisconsin – Jacke Harris, TE, Bucs
- Dallas – Carlos Huerta, K, Bears
- Richmond – Wayne Chrebet, WR, Jets
- Richmond – Ronnie Harmon, RB, Oilers
- Richmond – J. J. Birden, WR, Falcons